Discuss and learn French: French vocabulary, French grammar, French culture etc.
French Vocab Games app for iPhone/iPad French-English dictionary French grammar French vocab/phrases
For the latest updates, follow @FrenchUpdates on Twitter!
These sentences are from a textbook
Q: Est-ce que vous vendez des legumes?
A: Non, je ne vends que des fruits
Q: Est-ce que vous vendez des fruits?
A: Non, je ne vends que des legumes.
I don't understand why the answer to the question "Do you sell vegetables?" should be "No, I don't sell fruits". And the answer to the question "Do you sell fruits" should be "No, I don't sell vegetables."
Shouldn't it be the other way around ?
Tags:
Hello.
"Est-ce que vous vendez des légumes ?" = "Do you sell vegetables ?" : it's right
But "Non, je ne vends que des fruits" is not a negative form even if there is the word "ne" because of the word "que"
"ne ....(verb) ... que" = "seulement" = "only"
So for your sentence :
"Non" is the answer
and there is an additional information "Je ne vends que des fruits" = "je vends seulement des fruits" = "I only sell fruits"
it's the same thing for the second sentence.
Salut!
Maintenant je tout comprends :) Merci!
just a little correction if you want :
Maintenant je tout comprends => it's "Maintenant je comprends tout"
in French these small words (pronouns, adverbs ...) are generally after the verb.
(I have exactly the same problem in English :-) )
© 2025 Created by Neil Coffey. Powered by