French Language

Discuss and learn French: French vocabulary, French grammar, French culture etc.

French Vocab Games app for iPhone/iPad French-English dictionary French grammar French vocab/phrases

For the latest updates, follow @FrenchUpdates on Twitter!

bonjour

 i have 2 questions

1-What does this phrase mean ? "c'est moi que , ne se dit pas "

2- There are lots of relative pronouns  in french language  , and this is  confused us as learners

for example :

 
masculin singulier : lequel, duquel, auquel.
féminin singulier : laquelle, de laquelle, à laquelle.
masculin pluriel : lesquels, desquels, auxquels.
féminin pluriel : lesquelles, desquelles, auxquelles.

my question is : Are  all these pronouns are common ? in other words : do  french people really use them in their daily life ?

i want to concentrate on spoken french only that's why i ask

 

merci a vous

 

 

Views: 282

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

These pronouns are common-ish when they're the object of a preposition. For example:

  Voici le papier sur lequel il a écrit la note.

Let's say, in this case they're more or less as common as you'd need to express this kind of relationship between two nouns.

Otherwise, where there is an alternative, they're essentially part of formal usage, so for example this:

  J'ai parlé avec Jean Moulin, lequel est malade depuis 2 mois.

would in everyday language be expressed e.g:

  J'ai parlé avec Jean Moulin, qui est malade depuis 2 mois.

But, what about the first question?

 

OK, I think what they meant with full punctuation is:

  "C'est moi que" ne se dit pas.

which means "People don't say 'C'est moi que'". I'm guessing with more context it would make sense.

(N.B. "C'est moi que..." is perfectly grammatical under the right circumstances, so I'm guessing the person is pointing out that "C'est moi que..." is not grammatical in a particular sentence.)

That's a surprise, Neil. I would have thought it was always "C'est moi qui..."

Well, you can have both. It depends on what you're saying...

  C'est moi qui ai vu Paul.

  I'm the one that saw Paul.

  C'est moi que Paul a vu.

  I'm the one that Paul saw.


RSS

Follow BitterCoffey on Twitter

© 2024   Created by Neil Coffey.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service